Emerging Economies May Not Save Us

As the US economy, as well as the Canadian and much of the European economies, sinks deeper into recession, many are pointing (maybe partly with great hope) that the emerging markets will bail-out the rest of the world by driving overall demand. Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be the case with emerging markets not only showing signs of weakness, but showing signs of even more drastic declines than what the developed economies are currently experiencing.

This graph is sourced from Charles Schwab's latest webcast and presents a diffusion index of developed (lower chart) and emerging (upper chart) economic forces. Essentially, a downward sloping line is a bad thing and an upward sloping line is a good thing. What I find most interesting about these charts is the leader-follower dynamic that appears to be taking place. While most analysts and market watchers have been pointing to China and India as possible saviors of the global economy with their fabulous growth rates, it now looks as though the declines in demand from the developed economies is beginning to take its tole on their markets. Moreover, it would appears as though the declines that they are now experiencing are more severe than what the developed economies have seen. 

Inflation appears to be the culprit here. While we've seen low single-digit rates, the developing markets (the blue, in the left-hand chart) are showing near-double-digit rates. More importantly, their pace of inflationary growth (the slope of the line) is noticeably more steep. This is primarily due to wage-pressures. While the US and other developed markets have not seen wages rise, this has not been the case in the developing economies. The rest of the world is facing much greater inflationary pressures than we are at home and this spells great trouble for them in the future. 

So what does this all mean for us at home? Well, put simply, we can't rely on any other economy to help bail us out. We are in a global economy, to be sure, but that economy is by no means uniform. The rest of the world, especially the developing parts of that world, are only beginning to enter their own recessions and everything points to their troubles being worse than anything we will see domestically. On the whole, of course, this suggests a very slow and long recovery. While the developed markets may be better prepared to recover sooner, we are no dependent on emerging markets just as they are dependent on developed markets. As they are likely to sink deeper than we are, their economic pains will most certainly ripple through the rest of the world.