Monday, June 16, 2008

More Information Is Always Better


There's a lot of talk about the SEC and its persisting investigation of the ratings agencies. The good news is that, at least it appears at this point, investors will be winners now matter what the outcome.

I wrote earlier about the SEC's consideration of a plan to require the ratings agencies to make their research material available to others. This, of course, would allow others (hopefully individual investors as well) will be able to assess risk-and-reward profile for a given investment - just as the credit ratings agencies do. The advantage is that investors could become less reliant on the AAA-ratings and could review the actual data that goes into such a rating. With the agencies being blamed for having rated mortgage-backed securities as tripple-A (the highest investment-grade rating) that subsequently defaulted and resulted in hundreds of billions of dollars in losses and write-downs.

Now, there's news that the SEC will offer the ratings agencies a choice between two possible outcomes. The first, will be a disclosure of the underlying information as I described above; the second will introduce a new rating scale that would help identify mortgage-backed securities and distinguish them from corporate bonds. While certainly not providing as much information, this too would work to make investors more aware of where they were placing their money and that's never a bad thing. So, no matter what happens, at least its comforting to know that we, lowly investors, will ultimately win.

No comments: